By John Hayden
A child actress willing to kill for a role. An autistic gay man looking for love. A progressive community that may not be as progressive as they want to believe. These are just some of the intriguing stories being told in the new season at Island City Stage (ICS).
The ICS team has been working all summer and has five amazing shows lined up, which will bow over the next year. While that may seem like plenty of time to pace themselves, much of the work has already been completed.
“It’s been very busy,” Artistic Director Andy Rogow told OutClique. “We have to cast all five shows pretty much all at once and we have a lot of roles to cast. We spent about three months doing casting calls and call backs.”
And once the actors get on stage, they need something to wear. Their former fabric supplier left South Florida and since quality costumes for the stage aren’t found rummaging through the racks at a mall, they need to go elsewhere.
“We have two shows that are big costume shows,” Artistic Director Martin Childers said. “Our costume designer went to New York to go fabric shopping.”
Community Is A Class Act
Island City Stage has long been a fixture on Dixie Hwy. and has paved the way for the area to become the arts and entertainment corridor it is today. With The Foundry Theater next door, Empire Stage down the street and lots of arts galleries, the area is a cultural epicenter for small-to-midrange theater.
From Rogow’s perspective, the community benefits from all the venues.
“My favorite thing is that it’s so active and keeps growing. We now have all these art galleries that have opened,” said Rogow. “I love that Dixie Hwy. is becoming this arts corridor. And people are patronizing all these organizations.”
But quality art is expensive and government grants across the country, and especially in Florida, have been drying up. While Childers continues to apply, he is very appreciative of local donors and organizations.
“A lot of our grant funders are still supporters and we’re grateful. When you come to individuals in our community they are supportive. We couldn’t do it without them,” said Childers.
He knows how special this area is and knows what can happen without the love and support of a community. His previous theater company in eastern Kentucky closed due to lack of funding. While that makes him incredibly sad, he’s also incredibly grateful to be here.
“For me it was a great move. I’m happy to be here and be in the community,” he said.
Childers said the ICS community is tightly knit.
“People tell me they feel like family here. They are supporting. That’s the kind of community we want to build. We want to do excellent theater but we also want to have people that become our friends because they support what we do. There is so much happening. We have great neighbors and businesses that help any way they can. We are fortunate to be here,” he said.
“You realize WM is a really unique area, and what we have here is not easily found elsewhere,” Rogow added.
Sneak Peek
With casting completed and costuming underway, Rogow is giving OutClique readers an inside look at the upcoming season.
Ruthless! The Musical
Nov. 6-Dec.7, 2025
Book and Lyrics by Joel Paley
Music by Marvin Laird
Tagline: She’s Cute.She’s Sweet. She’ll kill for the lead
“It’s a very campy, funny musical. It’s about an eight year old girl who’s willing to kill to get the lead in the school play,” said Rogow, who is also directing the play.
The show is based on the campy showbiz movies of the 1950s and was a huge success off-Broadway and one production starred a pre-Disney Britney Spears. ICS has been trying to produce the show since before pandemic and now it’s finally here.
The Little Foxe$
Jan. 8-Feb. 1, 2026
Book by Lillian Hellman
Tagline: Greed runs in the family
“It’s the classic Lillian Hellman play,” Rogow said. “The movie starred Bette Davis. A lot of our audience will know this and have grown up with it. Our audience really loves these classic plays and our audience members are really excited.”
The story revolves around a very greedy family trying to build a cotton producing factory and how they manipulate each other and try to get their share of the money. It’s all about greed and family dynamics.
Everything Beautiful Happens At Night
April 2-26, 2026
Book by Ted Malawer
Tagline: A story can change everything
“This is about a gay man who’s closeted who is an illustrator and writer of children’s books. He writes a book that expresses who he is fully. It’s a beautiful story,” Rogow said.
Childers added, “I love this show. Near the end there’s something that happens that broke my heart and I love it.”
The show is set in the late 1980s and follows an author who brings his true self to light. Getting the show to ICS wasn’t easy. Rogow pursued the playwright until he gave permission to bring it to Wilton. This is only the second production of the show, following its debut in Sacramento.
Rogow says landing a new show requires trust between a writer and a theater company.
“It depends on how new the play is. Playwrights are also managing careers and want best exposure. But they also want to make sure the right theaters are doing the play, that it’s getting the proper attention. Good cast, good director attached.”
Light Switch
May 21-June 14, 2026
Book by Dave Osmundsen
Tagline: What if the switch never flips?
Light Switch tells the story an autistic gay man trying to find love. Rogow says it’s the type of story that’s perfect for this company. “What’s a unique story to tell? What have we not heard before? What isn’t part of the tried and true tropes we see in theaters? This is a no-brainer.”
Finding this play was a happy accident of sorts. The show debuted in Chicago where one of ICS’s patrons was in the audience and saw the show in Chicago and went to the playwright himself. Like Everything Beautiful Happens at Night, this is only the second production of the show. Rogow says the show has a beautiful ending and is “a great, great play.”
Eureka Day
Aug. 20-Sept. 13, 2026
Book by Jonathan Spector
Tagline: Outbreaks, outrage, and organic snacks
“This is the play I’m most excited about. It just won a Tony Award for best revival,” Rogow said. He will also be directing the production.
The show is set in Berkeley, California, which is known as one of the most liberal and progressive places in the world. But sometimes words don’t match deeds. After a mumps outbreak at a progressive, private school, the debate on how to move forward, including if vaccinations should be required, becomes heated.
Rogow says there’s a great scene where parents are meeting on Zoom and the audience reads the comments as they flash above the stage. After waiting years for the show to play on Broadway and in London, Rogow is excited to bring it to South Florida.
“It’s very moving and so relevant to what’s happening today. Even the most progressive people can get very nasty. When you try to be all inclusive, you’re still going to exclude somebody.”
You can learn more about the shows and get single show tickets or season passes by visiting IslandCityStage.org.
